Nov2026
Smiling businessman in a suit with colleagues behind him

By Sam Setyan | Updated November 21, 2026

People who search for EEOC discrimination cases won usually want one thing: proof that employees actually beat their employers. They do.

Below is a case file of real wins, from a 2026 jury verdict our firm obtained against Costco Wholesale Corp. to Supreme Court rulings that changed the rules for every worker, plus recent settlements the EEOC announced in 2026.

Case Type Year Outcome
Talamantes v. Costco Disability 2026 $200,000 unanimous jury verdict
EEOC v. Abercrombie & Fitch Religion 2015 Supreme Court win; $25,670 to applicant
Young v. UPS Pregnancy 2015 Supreme Court win; later settled
Bostock v. Clayton County (with Harris Funeral Homes) Sexual orientation and gender identity 2020 Supreme Court win; $250,000 settlement in companion case
Groff v. DeJoy Religious accommodation 2023 Supreme Court win; reported $1 million settlement
Muldrow v. City of St. Louis Sex (job transfer) 2024 Supreme Court win; case sent back for trial court review
EEOC v. Hi Tech Motorcars Sexual harassment and retaliation 2026 $925,000 settlement
EEOC v. Wagner Equipment Disability and retaliation 2026 $200,000 settlement
EEOC v. Lori’s Gifts Disability (hiring) 2026 $600,000 settlement
EEOC v. HCL America Age and national origin 2026 $495,000 settlement
EEOC v. DC Water Age 2026 About $217,000 settlement
EEOC v. Anthony Roofing Race and sex harassment 2026 $700,000 settlement
EEOC v. Metro Eighteen Race harassment and retaliation 2026 $70,098 settlement

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Every case depends on its own facts and law.

Setyan Law’s Own Result: The Costco Disability Verdict

Who: Aaron Talamantes, a probationary Costco Wholesale employee, represented by Setyan Law, APC and trial co-counsel.

What happened: Mr. Talamantes told his managers about his post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), anxiety, and physical limits from a past ankle injury that required surgical hardware. He asked for short breaks during panic attacks and limits on heavy lifting.

According to the evidence presented at trial, managers read his first doctor’s note as barring all lifting and put him on unpaid leave. A second note cleared him to return, but Costco did not follow up to discuss accommodations.

Outcome: In May 2026, a federal jury in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California returned a unanimous verdict for Mr. Talamantes and awarded $200,000 in damages.

The claims were brought under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA). Attorney’s fees are decided separately and add to an employer’s total cost.

Why it matters to you: Big companies don’t always follow their own accommodation process. If your employer misreads a doctor’s note, sends you home, and never talks to you about what you can do, that silence can be evidence.

Read our full write-up: Setyan Law wins disability verdict against Costco.

Source: Daily Journal, May 14, 2026

Key facts on EEOC discrimination cases won: $200,000 Costco verdict, 17.5% merit resolution rate, 3 years to file with the CRD
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Landmark EEOC and Supreme Court Wins

These cases did more than help one person. Each one changed the legal standard that applies to millions of workers.

EEOC v. Abercrombie & Fitch Stores (2015): religion

Who: Samantha Elauf, a Muslim teenager in Tulsa, Oklahoma, who wore a hijab.

What happened: She applied for a sales job. Abercrombie’s “look policy” banned caps, and the company didn’t hire her. It argued it never knew her headscarf was religious because she never asked for an accommodation.

Outcome: On June 1, 2015, the Supreme Court ruled 8–1 for the EEOC. An employer can’t refuse to hire someone to avoid accommodating a religious practice, even if the applicant never asked. Abercrombie then settled, paying Elauf $25,670 in damages plus $18,983 in court costs.

Why it matters to you: You don’t have to use the magic words. If the employer suspects you’ll need an accommodation and acts on that suspicion, it can be liable.

Source: EEOC press release, July 2015

Young v. United Parcel Service (2015): pregnancy

Who: Peggy Young, a UPS driver in Maryland.

What happened: When she became pregnant in 2006, her doctor told her not to lift more than 20 pounds. UPS gave light duty to some workers, including those hurt on the job, but not to her. She was placed on unpaid leave.

Outcome: On March 25, 2015, the Supreme Court ruled 6–3 that she could take her case forward. If an employer accommodates other workers with similar limits, it must justify why it won’t do the same for pregnant workers.

Young and UPS settled later that year on undisclosed terms.

Why it matters to you: Compare how you were treated with how coworkers with similar limits were treated. Today, the federal Pregnant Workers Fairness Act and California law give even stronger accommodation rights.

Source: Young opinion

Bostock v. Clayton County (2020): sexual orientation and gender identity

Who: Three employees whose cases were decided together: Gerald Bostock, Donald Zarda, and Aimee Stephens, a funeral director fired by R.G. & G.R. Harris Funeral Homes after she said she was transitioning.

What happened: Each was fired after their employer learned they were gay or transgender.

Outcome: On June 15, 2020, the Supreme Court ruled 6–3 that firing someone for being gay or transgender is sex discrimination under Title VII.

In the Harris Funeral Homes case, the company later agreed to pay $250,000: $130,000 in back pay and damages to Stephens’s estate and $120,000 in attorney’s fees. Stephens died in May 2020, weeks before the ruling.

Why it matters to you: Federal law now matches what California’s FEHA already said. Sexual orientation and gender identity are protected everywhere in the country.

Source: EEOC press release, December 2020

Groff v. DeJoy (2023): religious accommodation

Who: Gerald Groff, a Christian rural mail carrier in Pennsylvania.

What happened: After the Postal Service began Sunday Amazon deliveries, Groff asked not to work Sundays for religious reasons. He was disciplined for missed shifts and resigned in 2019.

Outcome: On June 29, 2023, the Supreme Court unanimously overturned the old rule that let employers deny religious accommodations if they cost more than a trivial amount.

Now an employer must show the accommodation would cause substantial costs in relation to its business. The case went back to the trial court, and Groff later settled with the Postal Service for a reported $1 million, which encompassed $400,000 in damages and $600,000 in legal costs.

Why it matters to you: It’s much harder for an employer to say “too inconvenient” when you ask for a religious accommodation.

Sources: Groff v. DeJoy opinion and Bloomberg Law on the settlement

Muldrow v. City of St. Louis (2024): job transfers

Who: Sergeant Jatonya Clayborn Muldrow of the St. Louis Police Department.

What happened: She was moved out of a specialized intelligence unit and replaced by a man. Her rank and pay stayed the same, but she lost her schedule, an unmarked take-home car, and FBI task force status.

Outcome: On April 17, 2024, the Supreme Court ruled 9–0 that a worker challenging a discriminatory transfer only has to show “some harm” to a term or condition of employment.

The harm does not need to be “significant.” The case went back to the lower courts.

Why it matters to you: A transfer, schedule change, or loss of duties can be discrimination even if your paycheck didn’t change.

Source: Muldrow opinion

Recent EEOC Settlements by Type

The EEOC also wins money for workers every month through lawsuits and consent decrees. A consent decree is a court-approved settlement that usually adds training, policy changes, and reporting to the EEOC. Here are recent examples, all announced in 2026.

Retaliation

EEOC v. Hi Tech Motorcars (Texas, July 2026). According to the EEOC, managers at an Austin car dealership sexually harassed four women in sales, and a male sales manager was transferred and then fired after he reported it.

The dealerships agreed to pay $925,000 to five workers under a three-year consent decree. Why it matters: You’re protected when you report harassment of a coworker, not just harassment of yourself. EEOC press release

EEOC v. Wagner Equipment (Colorado, October 2026). The EEOC alleged the company used screening standards that kept an employee with a disability from returning after medical leave, then refused to let her return after she asked for an accommodation.

Settlement: $200,000. Why it matters: Asking for an accommodation is protected activity, so punishing you for asking is retaliation. EEOC press release

Disability

EEOC v. Lori’s Gifts (Ohio, April 2026). A national hospital gift shop chain allegedly asked applicants about their physical abilities before making job offers and rejected candidates with disabilities. Settlement: $600,000.

Why it matters: Employers generally can’t ask disability-related questions before a job offer. EEOC press release

Age

EEOC v. HCL America (Northern California, April 2026). The EEOC alleged that a tech consulting company rejected an older applicant because of his age and national origin and hired a younger candidate. Settlement: $495,000 to the single applicant.

Why it matters: Age claims can be worth real money even when only one job is at stake. EEOC press release

EEOC v. DC Water (Washington, D.C., July 2026). According to the EEOC, the agency fired a high-performing older HR employee, replaced him with a much younger and less qualified worker, and skipped its own progressive discipline and appeal policies.

Settlement: about $217,000. Why it matters: When an employer ignores its own discipline rules, that can point to a hidden motive. EEOC press release

Race

EEOC v. Anthony Roofing (Illinois, November 2026). The EEOC alleged that a company executive and others regularly used racial slurs toward Black employees, and management failed to act after complaints. Settlement: $700,000.

Why it matters: Harassment by an owner or officer creates especially high risk for the company. EEOC press release

EEOC v. Metro Eighteen (Los Angeles, April 2026). A Black employee at the company’s Los Angeles location faced racially charged language from coworkers, complained, and was fired. Settlement: $70,098.

Why it matters: This is a local example of harassment followed by retaliation, the most common pairing we see. EEOC press release

How Often Do EEOC Charges Succeed?

The EEOC tracks something called a merit resolution. That’s any outcome favorable to the worker: a settlement, a withdrawal with benefits, or a finding that discrimination likely happened.

In fiscal year 2025 (October 2024 through September 2025), 17.5% of the charges the EEOC resolved ended in merit resolutions.

Other FY 2025 numbers from the EEOC’s own reports:

  • The agency resolved 90,744 charges.
  • It recovered almost $660 million for 17,680 people.
  • Of that, $528 million came through mediation, conciliation, and settlements before any lawsuit.
  • When the EEOC itself sued, it got a favorable result in 96.5% of the cases it resolved.

Many charges close because the agency can’t finish an investigation, the worker asks for a right-to-sue notice to go to court, or the paperwork is incomplete.

A closed charge is not a finding that you were wrong. And the EEOC’s lawsuit success rate is high because it picks strong cases. Most employees who win do it through their own lawyer, in court or in settlement.

Sources: EEOC FY 2025 Agency Performance Report and EEOC Office of General Counsel FY 2025 Annual Report

U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission seal on an office wall
Many California workers dual-file with the EEOC and the CRD.

What These Cases Mean for a California Claim

If you work in California, you have two sets of laws on your side: federal law enforced by the EEOC, and California’s FEHA, enforced by the California Civil Rights Department (CRD). FEHA usually protects you more:

  • It covers smaller employers. FEHA discrimination rules apply to employers with five or more employees. Title VII starts at 15.
  • It has no damages caps. Federal law caps compensatory and punitive damages based on employer size. FEHA doesn’t.
  • It gives you more time. You have three years to file with the CRD. The federal deadline in California is generally 300 days.

Dual filing means a charge filed with one agency is automatically shared with the other under a work-sharing agreement, so you preserve both state and federal claims. Many California workers file with the CRD, get a right-to-sue notice, and go straight to court under FEHA.

If you want to learn more about a demand letter at the settlement stage, read our guide to EEOC settlement demands with examples.

Talk to a Los Angeles EEOC Lawyer

The cases above have one thing in common: someone decided not to let it go.

If you were fired, demoted, passed over, or harassed because of who you are, our Los Angeles EEOC lawyers and discrimination lawyers can review your case and advise you on whether federal law, California law, or both offer the strongest path.

Call Setyan Law at 213-618-3655 for a free consultation. You pay no fee unless we win.

Frequently Asked Questions

Has anyone actually won an EEOC case?

Yes. Samantha Elauf, Peggy Young, Aimee Stephens’s estate, and Gerald Groff all won at the Supreme Court. In 2026, the EEOC announced individual settlements from about $70,000 to $925,000, and Setyan Law won a unanimous $200,000 jury verdict against Costco.

What’s the average EEOC settlement?

The EEOC doesn’t publish an average settlement amount. In FY 2025, it recovered $528 million for 13,351 people before any lawsuit, roughly $39,500 each. Large group cases push that number up, so many settlements are smaller. FEHA cases in California court have no damages caps.

Do I need a lawyer for an EEOC or CRD claim?

No, you can file on your own. But a lawyer can help you choose the right agency, meet every deadline, decide whether to request an immediate right-to-sue notice, and value your claim. Most of the large recoveries described above came after lawyers built the evidence.

Can I win a retaliation case even if my discrimination claim fails?

Yes. Retaliation is a separate claim with its own proof. If you reported discrimination or harassment in good faith and were punished for it, you can win on retaliation even if the conduct you reported turns out not to be illegal discrimination.

EEOC Lawyer - Call 213-618-3655